Sorry for the extended delay. Immediately after I said I would do it every other week, I got sick and then really busy and wasn't able to complete the next edition. We're back, though.
The rundown
(in no particular order)
- 1.
The big ASA State of Analytics for MLS is here, which is practically the same as Christmas morning for this newsletter. A record 3 (THREE) teams are now in the Nerd Boss tier, with the New York Red Bulls joining Colorado and San Diego up top. Additionally, a record 18 (EIGHTEEN!!!!!) teams are now in the "it takes a village" tier, meaning that they employ two or more analytics staffers. Just three clubs rank in the bottom-most tier with no analytics staffers — D.C. United, once a Nerd Boss club, have fallen from their pedestal under the tutelage of Erkut Sogut, LLM, Philadelphia Union recently lost both of their data people to Austin, and CF Montreal are just perpetually a mess (maybe some new owners will change that?). It's always fun to continue bullying clubs into hiring more analytics staffers.
- 2.
SkillCorner published a very interesting blog article by Victoria Friss de Kereki last week about how to build physical and performance-based profiles for scouting NWSL-ready wingers. I really liked how deep the author goes into these metric composites, and it's very nice to see a piece like this that incorporates physical data as well as event data. Of course, though, it also made me sad at how these things just aren't publicly available in the same way. We, the public, can make as many scouting profiles as we want, but I think there's an almost resignation to the fact that we can't incorporate physical data into these projects. That's frustrating to me because the public work in this space is missing something critical that is really only available to people already working in clubs. Imagine how much more research and ideas could be created simply from more eyes and hands on comprehensive up-to-date physical data! Maybe one day that will be a reality, and I logically understand the reasons why it isn't one right now. A girl can dream, though.
- 3.
This one's a belated update, since there hasn't been a newsletter since it dropped. For ASA, Nate Gilman took a stab at replicating comprehensive pressing metrics using just what is publicly available. It's especially pertinent for MLS, as "teams that press more are better." I liked a piece Nate added at the end about future areas to better break down pressing: "Trying to separate counterpressing versus pressure applied after stoppages of play might also be a worthwhile distinction to try to draw in the future... Right now, with the nature of event data, these ratings seem to be a measure of both how active and how effective a team’s pressure higher up the field is. However, there’s no distinction between a regain 40 yards from goal on the sideline and one on the edge of the box, and the latter is certainly more valuable for winning a soccer game than the former." This is essentially the classic question underlying EPV, it just surrounds something that we can't fully value in the same way without having comprehensive tracking-informed event data. Anyway, it's a good piece, and I like thinking about pressing.
- 4.
At The Transfer Flow, Neel Shelat analyzed the pros and cons of appointing Mauricio Pochettino as Manchester United's manager and why (big surprise), he probably isn't going to solve all of their issues. It's a good recap of his coaching resume and influence in the Premier League prior to the USMNT stint, and definitely worth the read for Manchester United fans and haters alike.
- 5.
Michael Caley is back with an update on the meatwallification of Premier League set pieces in 2026, and it seems that referees are finally putting a stop to the tactic this season. According to Caley, attackers are being called for fouls at a higher rate this season, while corner goals have plummeted from 0.48 per match last season to 0.28 per match this season — that's the lowest it's been in the past decade. There's more to the story, though. Here's the full piece.
The closer look: ASA survey
In conjunction with the MLS tiers list yesterday, Eliot McKinley and Ben Bellman released the results of this year's analytics survey on the ASA site this morning, and there's so much to dig into. It seemed that this year there was real progress in terms of investment in analytics and increased staffers, which is good to see. For the last two or so years, I've visited Teamworkonline on a fairly regular basis, and in the past few months, the volume of analytics-related postings has increased, as well. The variety of positions is changing, too. Where teams of the past have typically hired a single data analyst — and data engineer, if they're feeling crazy — job postings these days seem to have more variety in terms of responsibilities and career points. For example, the Portland Timbers, who recently hired a data analyst, are now hiring for an associate data analyst to work alongside side them and lead analytics operations for T2 and the academy. Likewise, LA Galaxy were hiring for associate data scientist recently, who would work in the department led by Ravi Ramineni. Finally, I would be remiss to mention a PAID internship that I saw recently at FC Cincinnati. The posting was for a 15 hour per week position during the 2027 sprint season, and the requirements were very reasonable for an internship. Realistic time expectations and compensating interns for that time is a rare thing, so I was really pleased to see that.
Back to the survey — that Chicago was ranked as the most analytically advanced club in 2026 should be no surprise. The club now have a whopping eight staffers, with various areas of expertise and focus. Kevin Minkus leads the operations and is an ASA alum, while GM Zayne Thomajan is a former American Soccer Insights Summit keynote speaker. Another trend that I noticed this year is the talent flows between clubs. With Jim Curtin's impending appointment at Austin FC, both Addison Hunsicker and Dean Costalas have followed him from Philadelphia, leaving the Union without analytics staffers. Khaled El-Ahmad has also joined Austin from Minnesota United, with Hank Stebbins now interim sporting director for the Loons. The aforementioned D.C. United, who lost all of their analytics staffers after Erkut Sogut took over last year, are still without a single analyst. Among the former D.C. staffers, while Kevin O'Donnell moved on to US Soccer, both Caleb Shreve and Eamon Dunlavey are now at St. Louis CITY. Blake Perry, who previously spent time at D.C. United and Vancouver Whitecaps, is now the Manager of Insights and Analytics at Orlando City, while Aidan Reynolds swapped STL for FC Cincinnati. Entire analytics departments have also risen from nothing this season. Sporting KC, who had no one last season, now have Francisco Belo as VP of Data and three data analysts underneath him. The Galaxy, who added Ramineni in February of 2025, have now added two new staffers (one of whom was just hired). A lot of these changes haven't been fully reflected in the analytics survey rankings. As the ASA authors put it: "The survey is often a lagging indicator." The growth, though, and continued commitment to investing in talent and retaining those analytics practitioners within the league is incredibly promising. In a world where data-related jobs are notoriously uncertain and fickle, that so many names in the industry are finding other clubs to continue driving the field forward is awesome to see. This seems to be reflected in the survey question that asked "Does your organization have more or less analytics buy-in than this time last year?" The results were more conclusive than last year, with 17 out of 18 respondents saying "Yes."
It seems to me, as someone who missed the beginning era of MLS analytics, that we are now in a solidly post-first-mover world. For a while, Toronto and Seattle, who were the two first clubs to properly invest in analytics, dominated the analytics survey rankings. That is no longer the case. Now, with 21/30 clubs in Tier 1 or above, and nine clubs receiving 5+ votes for "most analytically advanced club", the league is in a much different spot. Chicago and Vancouver have catapulted themselves to the top by building big departments and prioritizing integration. Staffers with analytics-related backgrounds are continuing to rise the ranks and become Sporting Directors, General Managers, and more, leading to even more institutional buy-in. More and more entry-level positions are popping up, getting new talent into the industry. The ASA survey asked respondents how MLS ranks compared to other leagues, and this was the finding: "most respondents consider MLS to be a global leader in soccer analytics, especially in its weight class. However this is not a universal opinion, and the size of department staff is a big reason why." The next step is thus even more expansion; two data analysts are good, but three are even better, and so on and so forth.
Another impending change that will surely impact hiring cycles as well as how clubs allocate resources and conduct their operations is the upcoming schedule switch. Moving to a more European schedule means that recruitment, in particular, will be affected, which is one of the biggest areas of impact for analytics in MLS. Will that meaningfully increase the need for analytics staffers? It's unclear, but change is coming, and that may mean different strategies — and more data — are needed.
Here's where I plug myself. I'm graduating next May from Willamette University and will be looking to work team-side for a bit. If you know of any roles or opportunities, whether full-time or consulting, and you think I'd be a good fit, let me know. I'm hoping to stay on the west coast or work remote, but that's not a hard rule. Of course, my graduation date is a complication factor with hiring cycles, but I'm open to working part-time until then. I've done a lot of public work that should be a good example of what I can do, but I also have experience with software engineering and as an intern at various clubs. You can contact me at catalinabush05@gmail.com. Huge thanks in advance and I appreciate you all hanging with me as a find a good, sustainable cadence for this newsletter.